Ping not working

[Jags007]

Hi,

I have 2 servers on my network - 1 is a Win2k and the other Win2003 Enterprise. I'm not running any DNS or DHCP services on either. Th issue I have is that I can Ping from my internal network the Win2k server but I cannot ping the Win2003 server. I have installed Wingate 5.07 on the Win2K box and I have no problems. I have done the same on the Win2003 box and changed all the settings to mimic the Win2k box. When I diable Wingate on the Win2003 box my clients can Ping the Win2003 box. I re-enable it and the requests timeout. I have tried checking and unchecking the "let local PC's Ping interanally" but that does not seem to work at all. Any Ideas would be great.

[genie]

Do you see any firewall hits when pinging 2k3 box?